Join our newsletter.

When Torts and Crimes Meet

By John S. Benson, Senior Partner at Penglase & Benson, Inc.

When a person injures you the law calls it a “tort.” When a person breaks a law created by the legislature it is called a crime.

Most people who are harmed or injured when a crime is committed don’t realize that a tort has also been committed.

Because of this, you have the ability to sue the defendant even though they were also prosecuted for the crime. Thus when you are injured due to a drunk driver hitting your car you can sue for your personal injury.

Many personal injury attorneys rush in and file suit against the defendant while the criminal prosecution is ongoing. This is a mistake. By doing this the attorney has weakened the criminal case, and in turn weakened the civil case.

By filing a civil case, an opening is created for the defendant who can now attack the credibility of plaintiff. When the plaintiff testifies in the criminal case, the defense attorney will portray the plaintiff as being interested only in money. They will tell the jury that the plaintiff shaped their testimony to make the civil case better. If the criminal case falls apart, the civil case is weakened. In Pennsylvania, a criminal conviction for DUI is negligence per se in the civil case.

Its best to hire a personal injury attorney who is familiar with criminal law. Your attorney should work closely with the prosecutor and let them know that they will not file a civil case until the conclusion of the criminal case.

If the attorneys work closely they can often share information which will strengthen both cases. Many times the civil attorney can even get a statement from the defendant as part of a plea bargin in the criminal case.

The PA personal injury attorney should attend all criminal proceedings where they can interview other witnesses, gather information and maybe even listen as the defendant testifies.

By working together both cases are strengthened.

Related News & Articles

If you reach the point where you are unable to make decisions regarding your medical care due to advanced age, an accident or an illness, a living will, trust and durable...

Substance abuse complicates personal injury claims in ways many don’t expect. When a person is under the influence, they may not think clearly or act in safe ways, which impacts their...

As you exit the courthouse, you feel drained but relieved. The judge ordered your child’s other parent to pay you a weekly child support amount calculated according to your state guidelines....

Did a doctor ever give you a diagnosis and you had no idea what it meant? Its frustrating communicating with someone and not knowing what the other is saying. Clients meeting...

It often starts with small things. A child who used to run to the door when you arrived suddenly hangs back. Phone calls are cut short or ignored entirely. Soon, your...

If you completed the Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) program for a DUI in Pennsylvania, you likely walked out of court feeling a profound sense of relief. For years, the greatest comfort...

There’s a lot you can do with $10,000. You could travel, invest in property, remodel part of your home or buy a decent used car. It’s not change-your-life money, but for...

You have a Will! Congratulations. You are in the minority in the United States. Some surveys show that only 39% of people in the United States have a Will. When we...

You got probation and can breathe a huge sigh of relief now that you know you aren’t going to jail. But don’t forget, you aren’t free yet. Probation comes with conditions...

Every year, thousands of Pennsylvania residents either file a complaint or defend themselves in Small Claims Court. Often called a Justice of the Peace, Small Claims Courts in Pennsylvania are disigned...

Penglase & Benson, Inc. Attorneys at Law logo